Toni Storm's bizarre dog-themed tape revealed at WrestleDream
Content creator Astrid Pizarro found what became known as the Toni Storm Tapes during AEW WrestleDream in Florida.
The tapes arrived at the AEW office in Jacksonville, Florida, in a brown paper package tied with string that had no return address.
Inside were five analog cassettes featuring Toni Storm giving advice, having conversations, and showing her day-to-day life.
Renee serves as the narrator for the tapes, stating that no one has seen or heard from Toni since March 18, 2026.
Storm last wrestled at AEW Revolution where she defeated Marina Shafir.
The following episode of Dynamite revealed that Toni had been murdered, leading to an investigation that later went cold.
Story timeline · 5 reports
- Toni Storm Sends Strange Cassette Tapes at WrestleDreamToni Storm made her presence known at AEW WrestleDream in Florida without officially returning.
- Mysterious Toni Storm Tapes Surface at AEW WrestleDream With Clues About Her DisappearanceInside was a cassette marked Toni Storm Tapes, wrapped in paper stamped confidential with instructions to play me.
- On the Record: ‘Toni Storm Tapes’ Found By Content Creator At AEW WrestleDreamThe latest: the latest: It looks like the Toni Storm mystery has taken a new direction, with tapes of the AEW star ‘discovered’ at AEW WrestleDream.
- Toni Storm Tapes Surface At WrestleDreamContent creator Astrid Pizarro found five analog cassette tapes at AEW WrestleDream in Florida.
Sources: Wrestling Observer · Sports Illustrated · Ringside News · 411Mania. · Fightful